Adverse credit history is linked to an estimated 30% of tenant referencing declines, according to analysis from Propoly, which points to financial pressure on renters amid ongoing cost-of-living concerns.
The analysis drew on Propoly’s internal Rental Intelligence data on tenant referencing outcomes, including why applications fail and when applicants receive conditional approval instead of a decline. About 62% of tenants pass referencing checks outright, and a further 29% get conditional approval. Only 6.4% are declined.
Among declined applicants, 29.4% have at least one adverse-credit reason recorded, such as County Court Judgements (CCJs), poor credit scores or insolvency. CCJs alone feature in 14.8% of declines, which suggests past financial difficulty can remain a significant obstacle for renters looking for a new home.
Affordability leads tenant referencing declines
Adverse credit is not the only obstacle, however. Affordability is the most frequently cited primary reason for a decline, at 31.8% of declined cases, while 19.7% relate to insufficient or unverified proof of income. Employment circumstances, including zero-hours contracts, temporary work, employment of less than 12 months and contracts nearing their end, account for 6.2% of cited reasons. Suspected fraud accounts for 0.8%.
The findings also suggest that failing an individual referencing requirement does not necessarily mean outright rejection. Of references with an affordability result, 15.2% failed the affordability assessment. Only 9.5% of those were declined outright, while 54% were accepted with a guarantor or other conditions and a further 35% passed overall.
Conditional approvals and alternative arrangements can help tenants secure a property when they do not initially meet every requirement. For applicants who fall short on affordability, for example, a guarantor can offer a route forward instead of automatic rejection.
“With the cost of living continuing to put pressure on household finances, it is perhaps unsurprising that credit history is playing a significant role in tenant referencing outcomes,” said Sim Sekhon, group chief executive of Propoly.
“Previous financial difficulties, missed payments or a CCJ can follow renters into their next property search, even when their circumstances may have since changed.
“However, it is important to remember that a failed referencing check does not automatically mean the end of the road. There is a difference between identifying a risk and ruling out a tenant altogether. Depending on the circumstances, options such as a rent guarantor or a conditional approval can provide a practical way forward for both landlords and tenants.
“Ultimately, tenant referencing should be about understanding the full picture, not simply looking for reasons to say no. By identifying where additional reassurance is needed, rather than treating every failed criteria as an outright rejection, the industry can help more people find a route into a home while giving landlords greater confidence in their decisions.”


