Deposit disputes rise by 25%

Deposit disputes rise by 25%

The latest TDS stats show that there has been a steep 25% rise in tenancy deposit disputes, with one-third of agents making claims.

This escalation in disputes is a worrying trend for agents and landlords and the key question is, what gives them the best chance of winning a deposit dispute – an in-house or third party inventory?      

Many agents instruct an independent third party to combat any conflict of interest issues that may arise in the event of a dilapidations dispute.  But, according to Imfuna Let, the UK’s leading inventory software solution, the independence and impartiality of a third party report can always be called into question, where the landlord or the agent instructs and pays their favoured independent provider to produce it.

Howard Lester, Director of Balgores Property Group comments: “Since the introduction of the Tenant Deposit Scheme, we have seen a steady and sharp rise in disputes. Over the last few years, these have changed in nature from the situations where agreement just couldn't be reached between the landlord and tenant, to parties just trying their luck as the realisation kicks in that the process is free of charge.

In order to reduce the amount of disputes, Balgores Lettings has been steadily increasing the quality of its inventories, using several apps over the last few years, with more photos and better descriptions. Additionally, we have employed our own clerks, improved the quality of their inspections and introduced pre-checkout visits to offer tenants advice on which items are likely to lead to deductions, if not corrected before the final checkout.


We have experienced a 25% fall in disputes requiring TDS adjudication, compared with last year.  We believe that by working with top inventory software companies, employing our own well trained clerks, as well as having a member of our management team who specialises in negotiating settlements, we have been able to buck the trend of rising disputes.

Perhaps one of the biggest help in this reduction has been the introduction of pre-checkout visits, where we are able to show the tenant the original inventory three weeks before the checkout.  We find very few issues when the final inspection takes place.

To make this work to its best ability, we have always looked to use the clearest and most concise inventories, so we are in the process of transferring to Imfuna Let. The software’s before and after pictures convinced us to switch. As well as being great for the tenants, we have found that landlords are more willing to accept wear & tear, as they are able to see the process throughout the tenancy with mid-term property inspection reports being sent to them.

Over the last 12 months, more than 65% of disputes have been settled in favour of the landlords we represent.  This goes to prove that if you have a quality inventory prepared, properly recorded inspections and checkouts carried out, then you are less likely to end up in a dispute with the tenant.”

Jax Kneppers, Founder and CEO of Imfuna Let comments: “The tenancy deposit is the tenant's money and the onus lies with the landlord to provide indisputable proof of dilapidations before compensation can be awarded. The deposit scheme adjudicators are only concerned with the evidence presented in support of a compensation claim and not the source of the inventory report documentation.  Who actually instructs and completes the inventory is irrelevant and to date there is no legislation to the contrary, which is extremely unlikely to change at any time in the future.  

Instructing an independent third party will not free the managing agent from their obligation to obtain quotes in support of any proposed deposit deductions after the check-out, or to negotiate a settlement with a potentially difficult tenant, who may be hell bent on initiating a dispute with the deposit scheme, regardless. Not to mention the landlord, who may not understand the concepts of fair wear and tear and betterment and whose future custom may well be at risk if an adjudicator's decision is unfavourable, as a result of a poor quality report supplied by the agent's recommended provider.

Inventory providers' terms are full of disclaimers, including responsibility for accuracy, which ultimately lies with the landlord. Any admission of liability for an error on their part will probably revolve around the volume of business received from the agent, which again contradicts the independence issue.

We offer agents a world-class inventory software application, Imfuna Let, which produces detailed, professional and branded in-house inspections reports from just £1 each. The software also provides a valuable new income stream.”

Join our mailing list:

Leave a comment



Latest Comments

Spencer Fortag
Spencer Fortag 30 Nov 2016

I am glad that someone listened to me!

view article
Tony Gimple
Tony Gimple 27 Nov 2016

It's not just the lack of estate agency advice that's costing landlords money; most are getting seriously bad advice from their accountants resulting in tax bills far higher than they need to be. Likewise,...

view article
Sally Walmsley
Sally Walmsley 18 Nov 2016

The RLA stands by its sell-off statistics. While we welcome the feedback from Mr Jagota and are delighted to hear how well things are going for landlords in the north east, we would like to make it clear...

view article
Sheryl87
Sheryl87 18 Nov 2016

The high employment levels and the vibrant economy has led to ever-increasing demand for rental properties, especially from professionals relocations from other cities. This has led to more experts teaming...

view article
Sheryl87
Sheryl87 18 Nov 2016

Renting out your house can be risky business. It's good to think about residential landlords insurance. Standard cover includes buildings cover and cover for loss of rent following damage to a property...

view article
AmberMorris
AmberMorris 09 Nov 2016

Fear of ghosts, really?? Ok, I get the fear of bats in the attic and mice and rats running under your nose - those are easy to deal with pest issues which are really unpleasant and can turn you off. But...

view article
AmberMorris
AmberMorris 08 Nov 2016

In my experience, It has always been a matter of discussion between the landlord and the tenant. There are cases when it's clear who's responsible for the pest control costs. I see a lot of people in forums...

view article
warren
warren 08 Nov 2016

There you go buddy :)

view article
Agent_PeeBee
Agent_PeeBee 07 Nov 2016

Any reason why my comment to this 'article' has not been published?

view article
Sean Lees
Sean Lees 04 Nov 2016

I don't think anyone can say dogs or cats are better or worse; depends on the animal, its age, how long it's left inside, etc. How bad the mess is depends somewhat on whether you are renting furniture...

view article
daniel black
daniel black 25 Oct 2016

I've been keeping a close eye on what the effect of Brexit has been on the rental market and it's a very mixed bag. Whilst the majority of the news focuses on London's market. I think this time next year...

view article
Northerner
Northerner 20 Oct 2016

Any views from outside the M25? No wonder politicians can't get the housing big picture when everyone seems to think that London is the yard stick, when it absolutely is not.

view article

Related stories

More articles from Landlords

Specialist Lending Roadshow 2017

24th-27th November

4 days
7 specialists
4 locations
Free to attend

Click here to register now