Deposit disputes rise by 25%

Deposit disputes rise by 25%

The latest TDS stats show that there has been a steep 25% rise in tenancy deposit disputes, with one-third of agents making claims.

This escalation in disputes is a worrying trend for agents and landlords and the key question is, what gives them the best chance of winning a deposit dispute – an in-house or third party inventory?      

Many agents instruct an independent third party to combat any conflict of interest issues that may arise in the event of a dilapidations dispute.  But, according to Imfuna Let, the UK’s leading inventory software solution, the independence and impartiality of a third party report can always be called into question, where the landlord or the agent instructs and pays their favoured independent provider to produce it.

Howard Lester, Director of Balgores Property Group comments: “Since the introduction of the Tenant Deposit Scheme, we have seen a steady and sharp rise in disputes. Over the last few years, these have changed in nature from the situations where agreement just couldn't be reached between the landlord and tenant, to parties just trying their luck as the realisation kicks in that the process is free of charge.

In order to reduce the amount of disputes, Balgores Lettings has been steadily increasing the quality of its inventories, using several apps over the last few years, with more photos and better descriptions. Additionally, we have employed our own clerks, improved the quality of their inspections and introduced pre-checkout visits to offer tenants advice on which items are likely to lead to deductions, if not corrected before the final checkout.


We have experienced a 25% fall in disputes requiring TDS adjudication, compared with last year.  We believe that by working with top inventory software companies, employing our own well trained clerks, as well as having a member of our management team who specialises in negotiating settlements, we have been able to buck the trend of rising disputes.

Perhaps one of the biggest help in this reduction has been the introduction of pre-checkout visits, where we are able to show the tenant the original inventory three weeks before the checkout.  We find very few issues when the final inspection takes place.

To make this work to its best ability, we have always looked to use the clearest and most concise inventories, so we are in the process of transferring to Imfuna Let. The software’s before and after pictures convinced us to switch. As well as being great for the tenants, we have found that landlords are more willing to accept wear & tear, as they are able to see the process throughout the tenancy with mid-term property inspection reports being sent to them.

Over the last 12 months, more than 65% of disputes have been settled in favour of the landlords we represent.  This goes to prove that if you have a quality inventory prepared, properly recorded inspections and checkouts carried out, then you are less likely to end up in a dispute with the tenant.”

Jax Kneppers, Founder and CEO of Imfuna Let comments: “The tenancy deposit is the tenant's money and the onus lies with the landlord to provide indisputable proof of dilapidations before compensation can be awarded. The deposit scheme adjudicators are only concerned with the evidence presented in support of a compensation claim and not the source of the inventory report documentation.  Who actually instructs and completes the inventory is irrelevant and to date there is no legislation to the contrary, which is extremely unlikely to change at any time in the future.  

Instructing an independent third party will not free the managing agent from their obligation to obtain quotes in support of any proposed deposit deductions after the check-out, or to negotiate a settlement with a potentially difficult tenant, who may be hell bent on initiating a dispute with the deposit scheme, regardless. Not to mention the landlord, who may not understand the concepts of fair wear and tear and betterment and whose future custom may well be at risk if an adjudicator's decision is unfavourable, as a result of a poor quality report supplied by the agent's recommended provider.

Inventory providers' terms are full of disclaimers, including responsibility for accuracy, which ultimately lies with the landlord. Any admission of liability for an error on their part will probably revolve around the volume of business received from the agent, which again contradicts the independence issue.

We offer agents a world-class inventory software application, Imfuna Let, which produces detailed, professional and branded in-house inspections reports from just £1 each. The software also provides a valuable new income stream.”

Join our mailing list:

Leave a comment



Latest Comments

ChristinaReedUK
ChristinaReedUK 20 Jun 2016

I don't understand why it's always a war between the two sides. Either, way the landlord is probably keeping a detailed inventory and will see the changes you've made. I just don't understand why there...

view article
NathanGreen
NathanGreen 16 Jun 2016

Seeing that the tenants are quite satisfied with their landlords and the properties is indeed great. I wonder, though, what is the situation in London alone? The tenants face sky-high rent levels in the...

view article
AndiMur
AndiMur 15 Jun 2016

TheGuardian published the same forecast. But on the other hand, professional brokers express different opinions. According totranio.com, an exit from the EU would not affect the demand/supply imbalance...

view article
Gary Holmes
Gary Holmes 14 Jun 2016

Having a professionally completed inventory at check-in and check-out is clearly (to me at least) of minor value. Tenants make un-authorised modifications and/or walk off with items that belong to the

view article
Violet Gibson
Violet Gibson 14 Jun 2016

Cautious people think buying off-plan is reckless, but over the past few years investors have literally made fortunes.Pre-release prices have obvious benefits for the developer, who gets instant finance...

view article
Kate Windleton
Kate Windleton 14 Jun 2016

An interesting research indeed. I guess that is in complete contrast with the United States where people often move from one coast to another. It will be interesting to hear the trends for people moving...

view article
NathanGreen
NathanGreen 14 Jun 2016

I think it all depends on the market conditions and how well your company is doing. You will agree that you can't demand more when you're killing yourself just to hang in there. Sometimes you need all

view article
ChristinaReedUK
ChristinaReedUK 13 Jun 2016

What does "detecting a bad vibe" mean actually. I've had certain vibes like these and yet have always found a reason , if there's any, why I don't like a certain property. The property maintenance might...

view article
keybanks estates
keybanks estates 08 Jun 2016

Great News for first time buyers, about time two!

view article
NathanGreen
NathanGreen 07 Jun 2016

I agree with #6 - you should maintain your garden according to the target buyer. One thing is universal, though - cleanliness and order. Having the yard clutter-free and clean will help people who do enjoy...

view article
NathanGreen
NathanGreen 06 Jun 2016

I will always say that London is overrated. Sure it is the capital, but it's too stuffed in there. It's more of a business city to me.

view article
Paul
Paul 25 May 2016

Estate agents are pathetic when it comes to fees. They have this 'I had to do it at 1% because that's what the others were quoting' mentality. We are the most expensive agents in our area, charging double...

view article

Related stories

More articles from Landlords